Lapeer's 1% Income Tax: What We Pay, Where It Goes, and Can We Do Without It?
If you live or work in the City of Lapeer, you're probably familiar with its 1% income tax. It's been around for decades, showing up on paychecks and tax returns for generations of residents. But with renewed discussion about whether the city should reduce or eliminate the tax, more people are asking where that money goes and whether Lapeer residents are paying more than people in other Michigan communities.
It's a fair question, especially when you consider that homeowners also pay property taxes.
But there's quite a bit to consider before deciding whether Lapeer could afford to lose a major source of revenue. The city operates its own police department, maintains streets and public property, and provides fire and rescue services to an area considerably larger than the city itself.
Those services aren't free, and they're not something most residents would want to see reduced.
At Lapeers Best, we're proud supporters of our local police officers, firefighters, and the people who work every day to keep our community safe and running. We also believe residents should understand how their tax money is collected and spent.
With that in mind, we looked at Lapeer's published financial records, municipal budgets, fire department reports, and Michigan Department of Treasury figures to get a better understanding of what we're paying for.
How Does Lapeer's 1% Income Tax Work?
Lapeer is one of 24 Michigan cities that collect a municipal income tax. Most communities in the state don't have one.
City residents generally pay 1% on taxable income, including income earned outside Lapeer. Nonresidents generally pay 0.5% on eligible income earned from work performed within city limits.
Certain business income is also subject to municipal income tax.
For a city resident earning $60,000 in taxable income, the 1% tax works out to $600 annually before applicable exemptions or adjustments. Someone living outside the city but earning that same amount entirely from work performed in Lapeer would generally pay $300.
Keep in mind that having a Lapeer mailing address doesn't necessarily mean someone lives within city limits. Many Lapeer addresses are located in surrounding townships, where the city's resident income-tax rate doesn't apply.
How Much Money Does Lapeer Collect?
According to the city's audited financial statements for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2024, Lapeer's General Fund received $5,145,548 in income tax revenue.
During that same fiscal year, General Fund property-tax revenue totaled $2,279,369.
That means income taxes provided more than twice as much General Fund revenue as property taxes.
With total General Fund revenue of approximately $11.94 million, income taxes accounted for about 43% of the money available to support city operations.
These are actual figures from the city's 2024 audit, not estimates of 2026 collections. Nevertheless, they show just how much the city depends on income tax revenue.
Removing a revenue source that accounts for more than 40% of the General Fund would require some significant financial changes.
Where Does the Income Tax Money Go?
The income tax doesn't go into a separate account reserved for one particular department.
Instead, it's deposited into the General Fund, where it's combined with property taxes, state revenue sharing, fees, and other revenue.
That money helps pay for many of the services city residents depend on.
- Police protection, including personnel, vehicles, equipment, training, and department operations.
- Fire and rescue services, including emergency response, training, equipment, and department operations.
- Public Works operations and maintenance of municipal property.
- City administration, financial services, and the Clerk's office.
- Planning, property assessing, and other city functions.
- Transfers to other funds supporting municipal activities.
The city doesn't assign each resident's income-tax payment to a particular department. The City Commission approves expenditures through the budget process, using the General Fund and other available revenues.
It's also worth remembering that local government has expenses residents don't always see. Maintaining police vehicles, replacing aging fire equipment, providing employee training, keeping public facilities in working condition, and meeting retirement obligations all require ongoing funding.
Those expenses are part of operating a community, even when they aren't particularly visible.
Police and Fire Protection Are a Major Part of the Picture
There's a reason public safety deserves special attention in any conversation about city finances.
When someone calls 911, they expect help. They aren't thinking about the city's General Fund, property-tax millages, or whether income tax collections increased last year.
They expect police officers and firefighters to have the training, equipment, and personnel needed to respond.
Lapeer operates its own police department, providing a dedicated local law enforcement presence within the city.
The department's responsibilities extend beyond emergency calls. Officers also handle investigations, traffic enforcement, community safety concerns, and other work that comes with protecting a city.
Maintaining those services requires consistent funding. Police vehicles need to be replaced, equipment needs to be maintained, and officers need training. Recruiting and retaining qualified personnel also costs money.
Lapeer Fire & Rescue has similar needs, with the added responsibility of maintaining expensive firefighting apparatus, rescue equipment, and protective gear.
Lapeers Best has long valued the work of our local police and fire departments. We believe keeping these services properly staffed, equipped, and funded should remain a priority whenever changes to city revenue are considered.
Lapeer Fire & Rescue Protects More Than City Residents
One interesting fact about Lapeer Fire & Rescue is that it serves a much larger area than the City of Lapeer itself.
According to the department's 2024 annual report, its service area covers approximately 100 square miles, including the City of Lapeer, Lapeer Township, Mayfield Township, and the southern portion of Oregon Township.
The surrounding townships receive fire protection through agreements with the city and contribute toward the cost of those services.
During 2024, Lapeer Fire & Rescue responded to 489 calls for service. Of those, 275 occurred within city limits, representing approximately 56% of the total.
The remaining calls involved the contracted townships or mutual and automatic aid to neighboring departments.
Those figures show just how important the department is throughout the surrounding area.
They also raise a financial question worth answering: How much of the department's operating cost is paid by the city, and how much is recovered through township contracts?
The number of calls in each community doesn't necessarily reflect its share of expenses. A major structure fire can require more time and resources than numerous smaller incidents.
A proper financial comparison would need to examine the township agreements, payments, staffing, equipment costs, and other expenses.
What Does the Fire Department Cost?
Lapeer Fire & Rescue's 2024 annual report lists an approved operating budget of $1,213,611 for fiscal year 2024-2025.
The department operates with a combination of full-time, part-time, and paid-on-call personnel.
Its expenses include far more than emergency responses. Firefighters need training, vehicles require maintenance, equipment must be inspected and replaced, and the department provides prevention and inspection services.
Fire apparatus can remain in service for many years, but eventually it needs to be replaced. The cost of doing so can be substantial.
As residents consider the city's tax structure, those long-term expenses deserve attention. A budget may cover today's operating costs while still needing to prepare for major equipment purchases years down the road.
How Much Does Lapeer Spend on City Services?
The city's 2024 audited financial statements reported approximately $5.85 million in public safety expenses, $4.34 million in public works expenses, $2.27 million in general government expenses, and $2.44 million in culture and recreation expenses across governmental activities.
These totals include spending supported through multiple funding sources. They aren't simply a breakdown of where income-tax dollars went.
Still, they help illustrate the scale of providing city services.
It's reasonable for residents to ask whether money is being spent efficiently. Every organization, including local government, should regularly review expenses and look for ways to operate more effectively.
But it's also necessary to understand what an expense pays for before assuming it can be eliminated without affecting services.
What About Lapeer's Property Taxes?
City homeowners pay property taxes in addition to the municipal income tax, although not everything on their property-tax bill goes to the City of Lapeer.
Property taxes also support schools, county government, and other taxing authorities.
Lapeer's city property-tax levy was listed at 9.8 mills in its proposed 2025-2026 budget.
One mill equals $1 in taxes for every $1,000 of taxable property value. A home with a taxable value of $100,000 would therefore generate $980 annually at a 9.8-mill rate.
That's the city levy, not the entire property-tax bill.
According to the city's 2024 audit, the 9.8 mills included 8.8 mills associated with general operations, 0.5 mill transferred to the Local Street Fund, and 0.5 mill transferred to the Capital Improvement Fund.
Michigan calculates property taxes using taxable value, which isn't necessarily the same as market value. A longtime homeowner's taxable value may be considerably lower than what the property would sell for.
How Do Lapeer's Taxes Compare With Other Michigan Cities?
Michigan Department of Treasury figures show that Lapeer's total property-tax rate is lower than those in several nearby cities.
According to the state's 2025 report, total homestead property-tax rates within the principal school districts for these communities were:
- Lapeer: 29.3642 mills.
- Imlay City: 43.0649 mills.
- Davison: 45.0464 mills.
- Port Huron: 41.3099 mills.
These figures include applicable city, county, school, and other property taxes, rather than just municipal operating millages.
For a home with $100,000 in taxable value, that works out to approximately $2,936 annually in Lapeer, $4,306 in Imlay City, $4,505 in Davison, and $4,131 in Port Huron.
Of course, Lapeer's 1% income tax must also be considered.
What Happens When We Combine Income and Property Taxes?
Let's use a homeowner with $100,000 in taxable property value and $60,000 in annual municipal-taxable income.
For this example, we'll assume the home qualifies for the principal residence exemption, the resident's income is taxable at the full applicable city rate before exemptions or adjustments, and no additional city income tax applies because of where the person works.
The approximate annual combined totals would be:
- Lapeer: $3,536.
- Imlay City: $4,306.
- Davison: $4,505.
- Port Huron: $4,731.
Under those assumptions, the Lapeer homeowner would pay less in combined property and municipal income taxes than the comparable homeowner in any of those three cities.
That may surprise some people, considering Lapeer's income tax often receives more attention than its comparatively low property-tax rate.
But the calculation changes as income increases.
At $150,000 in taxable annual income, the same Lapeer homeowner would pay approximately $4,436 in combined property and income taxes.
At that point, Lapeer becomes more expensive than Imlay City in this example, although it's still slightly below Davison.
At $200,000 in taxable income, Lapeer's combined total reaches approximately $4,936, exceeding both cities.
These are examples, not actual household tax bills. The results change with taxable property value, income, exemptions, and other factors.
Where Does Lapeer Stand Statewide?
Lapeer is one of 24 Michigan cities collecting a municipal income tax. Most of those cities use the same 1% resident and 0.5% nonresident rates.
Detroit, Highland Park, Grand Rapids, and Saginaw have higher resident income-tax rates.
However, comparing income-tax rates alone doesn't tell us which cities have the highest combined taxes.
A proper statewide comparison would need to calculate property and municipal income taxes for the same hypothetical household in every Michigan city, using the appropriate school district and property-tax rate.
The Michigan Department of Treasury provides statewide property-tax information, but it doesn't publish a ready-made combined property-and-income-tax ranking.
Without completing those calculations, assigning Lapeer an exact statewide position would be guesswork.
What the figures do show is that a city income tax doesn't automatically mean residents pay more overall. Lapeer's lower property-tax rate can offset some or all of its income tax for certain households.
Can Lapeer Really Afford to Eliminate Its Income Tax?
This may be the biggest question in the current discussion.
It's one thing to say residents would benefit from paying less in taxes. Most people would welcome having more money left in their paycheck.
But how would Lapeer continue paying for police protection, fire and rescue services, street maintenance, and everything else if a major source of revenue disappeared?
The city's financial records show why that question deserves serious attention.
In fiscal year 2024, Lapeer received approximately $5.15 million in income tax revenue, accounting for about 43% of its General Fund revenue.
That's a substantial amount to replace.
And according to the city's proposed 2025-2026 budget, Lapeer was already planning to spend more from its General Fund than it expected to receive during that fiscal year.
The proposal listed $11,732,477 in revenue and $12,815,247 in expenditures, a difference of approximately $1.08 million.
The proposed budget would cover that difference through available fund balance, reducing the projected unreserved balance from approximately $4.78 million to $3.69 million.
Those were proposed figures, not final audited results. Still, they demonstrate why the city needs to consider its existing spending and reserves before making substantial changes to revenue.
What Would a Gradual Tax Reduction Cost?
Using the city's 2024 income-tax collections as a rough starting point, a proportional 10% reduction in revenue would mean approximately $515,000 less annually.
A 25% reduction would mean roughly $1.29 million less. A 50% reduction would mean approximately $2.57 million less.
Complete elimination would remove approximately $5.15 million in annual revenue if collections otherwise remained at the 2024 level.
These are illustrations, not forecasts. Actual revenue changes would depend on how resident, nonresident, and business tax rates were adjusted, along with changes in taxable income and other factors.
Even a relatively modest reduction would involve hundreds of thousands of dollars each year.
What Would That Mean for Police and Fire?
This is where the consequences of any tax reduction deserve careful consideration.
Police and fire protection are among the services supported by the city's finances. If the General Fund receives substantially less money, the city would need to find other revenue, reduce expenses, or use available reserves to keep funding its operations.
That doesn't mean every dollar of lost income tax revenue would automatically come out of police or fire budgets. Those decisions would be made through the budget process.
But it would be unrealistic to remove millions of dollars in annual revenue without examining the effect on departments that depend on the General Fund.
A reduction that leaves less money available for personnel, training, equipment, vehicles, or future replacement needs could eventually affect the services residents depend on.
Lapeers Best believes protecting police and fire services should be a priority in any discussion about changing the city's taxes. These departments are essential to the safety of our residents, businesses, and visitors.
It's also worth recognizing that the people working in those departments make long-term commitments to the community. Funding decisions can affect recruitment, retention, equipment planning, and the ability to prepare for future needs.
We certainly support examining whether the city can operate more efficiently. But any savings plan should clearly explain how public safety and other essential services would be maintained.
Could Property Taxes Replace the Lost Revenue?
Not under the property-tax limits described in the city's 2024 audit.
The audit states that Lapeer's charter generally limits its property-tax levy for general governmental purposes to approximately 10 mills, excluding qualifying debt-service taxes.
With the city already levying 9.8 mills, the audit estimated that only about $40,421 in additional annual property-tax revenue could have been raised before reaching the applicable limit, based on the taxable property value at that time.
That's nowhere near the $5.15 million collected through the income tax.
So simply increasing property taxes within the existing charter limit wouldn't solve the problem.
Could Other Revenue or Spending Reductions Make It Possible?
Possibly. But there's a difference between identifying a potential source of savings and demonstrating that it can replace millions of dollars every year.
The city could examine operating expenses, future growth in taxable property values, development-related revenue, and other legally available funding options.
Some additional revenue might also become available as certain tax increment financing arrangements expire or change.
However, any revenue from those arrangements would need to be calculated carefully. Not every dollar captured through a development authority would necessarily return to the city's General Fund.
One-time savings present another challenge. Delaying a capital purchase might reduce spending in one budget year, but it doesn't necessarily provide permanent savings in future years.
Replacing an ongoing tax requires an ongoing financial solution.
What About the Mayor's Proposed Feasibility Study?
In an October 31, 2026, interview with Lapeer First News, Mayor Jeramy Hing discussed a proposed review of the city's income tax.
The review would examine historical income tax revenue, administrative costs, possible phased reductions, and property-tax revenue that might eventually become available from expiring development financing arrangements.
Importantly, the proposal described in that interview calls for preserving city services and jobs while evaluating possible changes.
That point deserves attention. Studying whether a tax can be reduced isn't the same as deciding to cut public safety funding.
The study could help establish whether there is a financially responsible way to reduce the tax without affecting essential services. It could also demonstrate that significant reductions aren't currently practical.
Either result would provide useful information for residents and city officials.
The interview preceded the November 2, 2026, City Commission discussion. The final action taken at that meeting should be confirmed through official records before describing the study as formally approved.
What Would Make an Income Tax Reduction Feasible?
For Lapeer to reduce its income tax while maintaining current services, several things would need to happen.
First, the city would need reliable projections of its income tax collections and other revenue for the coming years.
Second, it would need to identify recurring savings or additional recurring revenue sufficient to offset the proposed reduction.
Third, it would need to account for future expenses, including police and fire equipment, infrastructure maintenance, employee obligations, and other costs that don't disappear when tax revenue declines.
Finally, the city would need to demonstrate that its financial reserves remain adequate to handle emergencies and unexpected expenses.
A multi-year financial plan would give residents a better understanding of whether a gradual reduction is realistic.
Under the figures available today, immediate elimination would create a substantial financial challenge. A smaller, phased reduction may be worth examining, but the city's published records don't yet establish that it could be accomplished without affecting services or requiring other changes.
What Questions Still Need Answers?
Before residents can evaluate a major change to the income tax, several questions deserve clear answers.
- How much income tax has Lapeer collected annually over the past ten years?
- How much comes from city residents, nonresidents, and businesses?
- What does the Income Tax Division cost to operate?
- How would different tax reductions affect the city's budget over five or ten years?
- What are the long-term staffing and equipment needs of the police and fire departments?
- How much of Lapeer Fire & Rescue's operating costs are recovered through township contracts?
- What recurring expenses could be reduced without affecting essential services?
- How much additional revenue could eventually become available from development-related financing arrangements?
- What level of financial reserves should the city maintain?
Having those answers would make the public discussion considerably more useful.
Where Does That Leave Lapeer?
There's no question that Lapeer's income tax provides a significant amount of money for city operations. There's also no question that residents have a right to ask whether their tax dollars are being spent wisely.
Our comparison with nearby Michigan cities shows that Lapeer's combined income and property taxes aren't automatically higher simply because the city collects an income tax. For some households, Lapeer's comparatively low property-tax rate more than offsets the additional tax on income.
For others, particularly those with higher taxable incomes, the calculation can be different.
But taxes are only part of the conversation.
Lapeer residents also depend on police officers, firefighters, Public Works employees, and others who provide the services that keep the city operating.
Lapeers Best appreciates the people who serve our community and the work they do every day. Maintaining properly funded police and fire departments is something we believe deserves particular attention as the city considers its financial future.
That doesn't mean the existing income tax should never be questioned or that city spending shouldn't be reviewed. Good financial management requires asking difficult questions and examining alternatives.
It does mean that any proposal to reduce or eliminate a major revenue source should come with a realistic plan for protecting the services residents depend on.
With more than $5 million in annual income tax revenue at stake, there's a lot to consider.
Residents deserve to see the numbers, understand the options, and know what any proposed changes would mean for the community.
Sources: City of Lapeer Audited Financial Statements for Fiscal Year Ended June 30, 2024; City of Lapeer 2024-2025 Adopted Budget; City of Lapeer Proposed 2025-2026 Budget; Lapeer Fire & Rescue 2024 Annual Report; Michigan Department of Treasury 2025 Total Property Tax Rates; Michigan Department of Treasury City Income Tax Information; Lapeer First News, October 31, 2026