Oakdale’s story spans nearly a century. It began with optimism—a belief that creating a specialized home for people with epilepsy and developmental disabilities would provide care and structure that families could not. It grew into a self-contained city that shaped the lives of thousands of residents and staff, influencing Lapeer’s economy, culture, and identity. And in the end, it faded into history, leaving behind a complex legacy that still stirs strong emotions today.
A Place of Shelter and Control
For some, Oakdale was a sanctuary. Families who were overwhelmed or unable to care for children with severe disabilities saw the institution as a lifeline. Residents had food, shelter, routine, and at least a semblance of community. Former staff recall laughter echoing through the cottages on holidays, residents dancing at summer picnics, and friendships that lasted for decades.
Yet Oakdale was also a place of control. Residents’ lives were dictated by schedules, rules, and policies they had no voice in shaping. Many entered as children and never left, growing old within the same walls. The institution’s embrace of eugenics—sterilizing hundreds under the guise of “progress”—and its use of forced labor cast long ethical shadows over its history.
Oakdale, like many institutions of its era, was built on contradictions. It was both a refuge and a prison, a place of care and a place of confinement.
The Ripple Effect on Lapeer
For Lapeer, Oakdale was more than just an institution—it was an economic and cultural anchor. Generations of families found employment there. Entire neighborhoods of Lapeer grew up around the needs of the state home, from housing for staff to local businesses supplying the institution.
When Oakdale closed in 1991, the impact was immediate. Hundreds of jobs were lost, and a piece of Lapeer’s identity disappeared. Even today, many longtime residents refer to directions by saying “near where Oakdale used to be.”
Lessons Learned
Oakdale’s rise and fall mirror America’s evolving understanding of disability and care. In the late 19th century, institutionalization was considered enlightened. By the mid-20th century, it was simply the norm. But as the civil rights movement broadened society’s view of human dignity and autonomy, large institutions like Oakdale came to be seen as outdated and, in many ways, unjust.
From Oakdale’s history, we’ve learned that:
-
Isolation is not care. Removing people from society can provide safety, but it also strips away freedom and community integration.
-
Policies need oversight. Eugenics and forced sterilization remind us how easily vulnerable populations can be exploited in the name of “progress.”
-
Community care is possible. Many former residents thrived in smaller group homes and supported living environments, proving that people do better in inclusive settings.
Preserving the Memory
Today, most of Oakdale’s buildings are gone, but its memory is preserved through local history efforts. The Oakdale Cemetery still stands as the most poignant reminder, with rows of simple numbered markers for residents who never left the grounds. Annual cemetery tours honor those lives, sharing the personal stories of people once known only by a diagnosis.
The Lapeer District Library holds a rich archive of photographs, newsletters, and records. The book Oakdale: The Lapeer State Home and the 1962 documentary A Wind is Rising give future generations a way to see inside an institution that shaped a century of local history.
The few surviving buildings—repurposed into schools and community spaces—stand as both practical resources and historical markers. They’re physical reminders that while institutions may vanish, their legacies remain.
Oakdale in Context
Oakdale was not unique. Across the United States, hundreds of similar institutions followed the same trajectory—born of reformist ideals, expanded into massive facilities, and eventually dismantled in favor of community-based care. But Oakdale’s story feels personal because it touched so many lives in one small Michigan county.
It reminds us how society’s views of disability and care can change over time—and how those changes affect real people.
The Human Stories Endure
In the end, Oakdale is remembered less for its buildings and policies than for the people. The residents who found friendship in a place that otherwise limited them. The staff who gave their working lives to care for others, even in a system that was imperfect. The families who had to make impossible decisions about loved ones.
Oakdale’s story is about what it means to care for those who are different, how we balance compassion with control, and how we remember those whose voices were too often unheard.
It is a story that still matters—not just for Lapeer, but for anyone reflecting on how we treat the most vulnerable members of our communities.
Key Details from Part 7
-
Oakdale’s legacy is both positive and painful, reflecting the care it provided and the freedoms it denied.
-
The closure impacted Lapeer’s economy and identity, ending a major source of local employment.
-
Its history teaches important lessons about disability rights, community care, and the dangers of unchecked policies.
-
Memory is preserved through the cemetery, archives, books, and tours, keeping Oakdale’s human stories alive.
Sources for This Article
-
Oakdale: The Lapeer State Home by William Fromwiller & Ron Gillis
-
Oral histories collected by the Lapeer Historical Society
-
The County Press retrospective series on Oakdale
-
Lapeer District Library Oakdale Gallery archives
-
1962 documentary A Wind is Rising